In this episode of The ARI Bookshelf, Jason Rheins, Ben Bayer, Don Watkins, and Alex Silverman examine two contrasting perspectives on the influence of Christianity: Tom Holland’s Dominion and Charles Freeman’s The Closing of the Western Mind and The Reopening of the Western Mind.
While Holland’s widely discussed book argues that Christianity is the foundation of science and Western values, Freeman’s books present a contrary view. Our panelists bring their expertise to evaluate the arguments in both books, assessing their historical and philosophical accuracy.
The discussion covered:
The central arguments of the books
Why the Church feared Aristotelian philosophy
How Freeman’s books provide a more thorough and philosophical analysis than Holland’s
How Holland diminishes Greek influence on modernity
How Holland appropriates secular ideas and thinkers into Christianity
The role of Christianity in the abolition of slavery
The relationship between Christianity and science
Why Holland’s book gained popularity while Freeman’s did not
The video premiered on March 11, 2025.
If you value the ideas presented here, please become an ARI Member today.
